Yes, thats right. have you seen this? So this is the end of the road for the trustworthyness of WG.
They have seen the 170+ pages of forumthread, and instead of addressing the issue, they try to silence us!
''No critisism allowed here''.
So 13 days left. If you dont sign the EULA, WG can terminate your account:
If you fail to comply with any of the terms set out in this section, we reserve the right to terminate your license over the Fansite Content and also to close your Account.
Her you will offer your surrender:
YOU FURTHER ACKNOWLEDGE AND AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO CLAIM, RIGHT, TITLE, OWNERSHIP, OR OTHER PROPRIETARY INTEREST IN THE ADDITIONAL FEATURES (AS DEFINED BELOW) THAT YOU UNLOCK OR ACCUMULATE, REGARDLESS OF ANY CONSIDERATION OFFERED OR PAID IN EXCHANGE FOR SUCH ADDITIONAL FEATURES.
YOU OWN NOTHING ANYMORE!
Here is WG covering their tracks for destroying a few years of fun:
URTHERMORE, WARGAMING SHALL NOT BE LIABLE IN ANY MANNER FOR THE DESTRUCTION, DELETION, MODIFICATION, IMPAIRMENT, HACKING, OR ANY OTHER DAMAGE OR LOSS OF ANY KIND CAUSED TO THE GAME CONTENT OR ADDITIONAL FEATURES, INCLUDING THE DELETION OF GAME CONTENT OR ADDITIONAL FEATURES UPON THE TERMINATION OR EXPIRATION OF YOUR ACCOUNT.
Also, you cant be a newsite anymore, you have to kiss their [edited]or you will be terminated;
the Fansite will not post material that is disparaging, illegal or infringes on the rights of any third party or that damages (or that might damage) the reputation of Wargaming or of any of the Games. If you fail to comply with any of the terms set out in this section, we reserve the right to terminate your license over the Fansite Content and also to close your Account.
They have seen that people dont like what they will do to prefferential MM tanks. They didnt kow it would be such a shitstorm. So they change the EULA so they can change the KV5 freely, and you can only comply. They will cough you up, and they will push this through your troat. They dont want a Foche debacle anymore.
I dont think the part where you cant critisise them anymore is legal, but the part of the ''changing'' is legal. They can do whatever they want!
We cant let this slide! this is a turning point, after this they can do whatever they want, and there will be no more respect to you, me or the whole community anymore! we have to do something!
Spoiler
Check out these amazing future additions to the WGNA EULA. Only 13 days left and they are getting applied.
„5.4 Ownership of Your Account. NOTWITHSTANDING ANYTHING TO THE CONTRARY HEREIN, YOU ACKNOWLEDGE AND AGREE THAT YOU SHALL HAVE NO OWNERSHIP OR OTHER PROPERTY INTEREST IN YOUR ACCOUNT, AND THAT ALL RIGHTS IN AND TO YOUR ACCOUNT ARE AND SHALL FOREVER BE OWNED BY AND INURE TO THE BENEFIT OF WARGAMING. YOU FURTHER ACKNOWLEDGE AND AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO CLAIM, RIGHT, TITLE, OWNERSHIP, OR OTHER PROPRIETARY INTEREST IN THE ADDITIONAL FEATURES (AS DEFINED BELOW) THAT YOU UNLOCK OR ACCUMULATE, REGARDLESS OF ANY CONSIDERATION OFFERED OR PAID IN EXCHANGE FOR SUCH ADDITIONAL FEATURES.FURTHERMORE, WARGAMING SHALL NOT BE LIABLE IN ANY MANNER FOR THE DESTRUCTION, DELETION, MODIFICATION, IMPAIRMENT, HACKING, OR ANY OTHER DAMAGE OR LOSS OF ANY KIND CAUSED TO THE GAME CONTENT OR ADDITIONAL FEATURES, INCLUDING THE DELETION OF GAME CONTENT OR ADDITIONAL FEATURES UPON THE TERMINATION OR EXPIRATION OF YOUR ACCOUNT.
9.3.1 you acknowledge and agree that Wargaming retains ownership of the Fansite Content, and any and all derivative works thereof, and has the right to amend, delete, add to or otherwise modify, or to revoke the foregoing license with respect to, any items of Fansite Content at any time;
9.3.6 the Fansite will not post material that is disparaging, illegal or infringes on the rights of any third party or that damages (or that might damage) the reputation of Wargaming or of any of the Games;
9.3.7 except as expressly permitted in this EULA, you shall not rent, lease, reproduce, modify, translate the Fansite Content, or make an adaptation of (including without limitation fiction or visual art), or in any way exploit, any of the Content without our express written permission; and
9.3.8 you must not make, or seek to make, any commercial use or profit out of the Fansite Content (including for example by selling subscriptions to your Fansite) without our prior written consent.
9.4 If you fail to comply with any of the terms set out in this section, we reserve the right to terminate your license over the Fansite Content and also to close your Account.
9.5 All goodwill arising from your use of Fansite Content, including from use of any trademarks owned by Wargaming, shall inure solely to the benefit of Wargaming.”
This is clear every time you write to support. You get nothing, you are nothing.
Only in gaming industry companies can do this to your face. Everywhere else you'd get compensated.
Darksteel_Plate, on 04 June 2018 - 05:53 AM, said:
Yes, thats right. have you seen this? So this is the end of the road for the trustworthyness of WG.
They have seen the 170+ pages of forumthread, and instead of addressing the issue, they try to silence us!
''No critisism allowed here''.
So 13 days left. If you dont sign the EULA, WG can terminate your account:
If you fail to comply with any of the terms set out in this section, we reserve the right to terminate your license over the Fansite Content and also to close your Account.
Her you will offer your surrender:
YOU FURTHER ACKNOWLEDGE AND AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO CLAIM, RIGHT, TITLE, OWNERSHIP, OR OTHER PROPRIETARY INTEREST IN THE ADDITIONAL FEATURES (AS DEFINED BELOW) THAT YOU UNLOCK OR ACCUMULATE, REGARDLESS OF ANY CONSIDERATION OFFERED OR PAID IN EXCHANGE FOR SUCH ADDITIONAL FEATURES.
YOU OWN NOTHING ANYMORE!
Here is WG covering their tracks for destroying a few years of fun:
URTHERMORE, WARGAMING SHALL NOT BE LIABLE IN ANY MANNER FOR THE DESTRUCTION, DELETION, MODIFICATION, IMPAIRMENT, HACKING, OR ANY OTHER DAMAGE OR LOSS OF ANY KIND CAUSED TO THE GAME CONTENT OR ADDITIONAL FEATURES, INCLUDING THE DELETION OF GAME CONTENT OR ADDITIONAL FEATURES UPON THE TERMINATION OR EXPIRATION OF YOUR ACCOUNT.
Also, you cant be a newsite anymore, you have to kiss their [edited]or you will be terminated;
the Fansite will not post material that is disparaging, illegal or infringes on the rights of any third party or that damages (or that might damage) the reputation of Wargaming or of any of the Games. If you fail to comply with any of the terms set out in this section, we reserve the right to terminate your license over the Fansite Content and also to close your Account.
They have seen that people dont like what they will do to prefferential MM tanks. They didnt kow it would be such a shitstorm. So they change the EULA so they can change the KV5 freely, and you can only comply. They will cough you up, and they will push this through your troat. They dont want a Foche debacle anymore.
I dont think the part where you cant critisise them anymore is legal, but the part of the ''changing'' is legal. They can do whatever they want!
We cant let this slide! this is a turning point, after this they can do whatever they want, and there will be no more respect to you, me or the whole community anymore! we have to do something!
Spoiler
Check out these amazing future additions to the WGNA EULA. Only 13 days left and they are getting applied.
„5.4 Ownership of Your Account. NOTWITHSTANDING ANYTHING TO THE CONTRARY HEREIN, YOU ACKNOWLEDGE AND AGREE THAT YOU SHALL HAVE NO OWNERSHIP OR OTHER PROPERTY INTEREST IN YOUR ACCOUNT, AND THAT ALL RIGHTS IN AND TO YOUR ACCOUNT ARE AND SHALL FOREVER BE OWNED BY AND INURE TO THE BENEFIT OF WARGAMING. YOU FURTHER ACKNOWLEDGE AND AGREE THAT YOU HAVE NO CLAIM, RIGHT, TITLE, OWNERSHIP, OR OTHER PROPRIETARY INTEREST IN THE ADDITIONAL FEATURES (AS DEFINED BELOW) THAT YOU UNLOCK OR ACCUMULATE, REGARDLESS OF ANY CONSIDERATION OFFERED OR PAID IN EXCHANGE FOR SUCH ADDITIONAL FEATURES.FURTHERMORE, WARGAMING SHALL NOT BE LIABLE IN ANY MANNER FOR THE DESTRUCTION, DELETION, MODIFICATION, IMPAIRMENT, HACKING, OR ANY OTHER DAMAGE OR LOSS OF ANY KIND CAUSED TO THE GAME CONTENT OR ADDITIONAL FEATURES, INCLUDING THE DELETION OF GAME CONTENT OR ADDITIONAL FEATURES UPON THE TERMINATION OR EXPIRATION OF YOUR ACCOUNT.
9.3.1 you acknowledge and agree that Wargaming retains ownership of the Fansite Content, and any and all derivative works thereof, and has the right to amend, delete, add to or otherwise modify, or to revoke the foregoing license with respect to, any items of Fansite Content at any time;
9.3.6 the Fansite will not post material that is disparaging, illegal or infringes on the rights of any third party or that damages (or that might damage) the reputation of Wargaming or of any of the Games;
9.3.7 except as expressly permitted in this EULA, you shall not rent, lease, reproduce, modify, translate the Fansite Content, or make an adaptation of (including without limitation fiction or visual art), or in any way exploit, any of the Content without our express written permission; and
9.3.8 you must not make, or seek to make, any commercial use or profit out of the Fansite Content (including for example by selling subscriptions to your Fansite) without our prior written consent.
9.4 If you fail to comply with any of the terms set out in this section, we reserve the right to terminate your license over the Fansite Content and also to close your Account.
9.5 All goodwill arising from your use of Fansite Content, including from use of any trademarks owned by Wargaming, shall inure solely to the benefit of Wargaming.”
and yet if they terminate accounts on those basis consumer rights stand before eula. sry - instead of buying premium time and tanks youll buy lawyer time.
Well... when you compare that to the other two tonk games.
Tonkthunder:
3.8. Agreement Suspension. WITHOUT LIMITING ANY OTHER REMEDIES, GAIJIN MAY LIMIT, SUSPEND, TERMINATE, MODIFY, OR DELETE ACCOUNTS OR ACCESS TO THE PRODUCT OR PORTIONS THEREOF IF YOU ARE, OR GAIJIN REASONABLY SUSPECTS THAT YOU ARE, FAILING TO COMPLY WITH ANY OF THIS AGREEMENT OR FOR ANY ACTUAL OR SUSPECTED ILLEGAL OR IMPROPER USE OF THE PRODUCT, WITH OR WITHOUT NOTICE TO YOU. YOU CAN LOSE YOUR USER NAME AND PERSONA AS A RESULT OF ACCOUNT TERMINATION OR LIMITATION, AS WELL AS ANY BENEFITS, PRIVILEGES, EARNED ITEMS AND PURCHASED ITEMS ASSOCIATED WITH YOUR USE OF THE PRODUCT AND/OR GAME, AND GAIJIN IS UNDER NO OBLIGATION TO COMPENSATE YOU FOR ANY SUCH LOSSES OR RESULTS.
Armored Tonkfare:
5.21. Should the the provisions of this EULA or any related documents be violated by the User, MY COM B.V. may apply the following sanctions:
restrict the use of in-game communication services;
partially restrict the Game functionality of an account and/or that of a character;
restrict the access to any components of in-game content;
perform a forced renaming of: a character, user communities or organizations, or in-game objects;
remove items, in-game currency, or other in-game valuables;
restrict, suspend, or completely terminate the access to one or more characters of a game account;
change the values of achievements and the parameters of the development of characters;
remove characters or accounts.
Depending on the violation and its consequences for the Game as a whole, the type and/or extent of a sanction may be changed at MY.COM B.V. discretion.
TAP got it wrong, even accepted he got it wrong in the comments, yet kept the article as it was. At least he did point out that it was only the NA EULA, unlike you.
No, you think you should be compensated because you adhere to the compensation culture. A car manufacturer changes the value of your car when they bring out the new model that replaces it, so does everybody get compensated? Things in life change, you don't need to be compensated every time they do.
Darksteel_Plate
#10
Posted 04 June 2018 - 08:25 AM
Staff Sergeant
Player
9987battles
306
Member since: 07-02-2013
Homer_J, on 04 June 2018 - 06:44 AM, said:
Ah, the Daily Mail of WoT.
TAP got it wrong, even accepted he got it wrong in the comments, yet kept the article as it was. At least he did point out that it was only the NA EULA, unlike you.
and were can i see if this is wrong? also, WG NA is owned by the same company that owns WG EU. so they will change it up anyways later.
We already have multiple threads about this on the first and second page here.
Do people never read the EULAs they agree to? Only when they make it into the news because one reason or another?
We have that kind of law gibberish since at least ten years now. Developers use it to protect THEIR property and to prevent random bobs from annoying or suing them when they want to fix balance issues.
The problem here is that all those rules get a quite different undertone when you have a company like WG sitting behind them...
Darksteel_Plate, on 04 June 2018 - 08:25 AM, said:
and were can i see if this is wrong? also, WG NA is owned by the same company that owns WG EU. so they will change it up anyways later.
First, the Fansite termination clause, is for fansites using WG fansite content (pictures etc.), which is protected by the WG IP. So, yes, if you are misusing said "fansite content", WG can terminate your account for that.
Second, WG NA is working as its own company, at least on the legal department part.
Third, as stated before, this is nothing new in the EULA, and termination without refund is legal (at least in Germany there are similar cases, where the game providing company won the dispute).
Yeah, a bit of a shame Wargaming is going full Gulag RASJA!!!1!!1 mode on people who point out their horsemanure tactics and changes.
I mean seriously? Terminating your *GAMEPLAY* account if you say bad things about Wargaming on the forums.......really?
250swb, on 04 June 2018 - 07:10 AM, said:
No, you think you should be compensated because you adhere to the compensation culture. A car manufacturer changes the value of your car when they bring out the new model that replaces it, so does everybody get compensated? Things in life change, you don't need to be compensated every time they do.
Error 404: Logic not found
An apt comparison would be if the car manufacturer would come over to your house and change the engine in your car for something worse without you approving of it. And then you *WOULD* have the right to compensation.
Just like in the case of the KV-5 where WG make the service you purchased (KV-5) worse than it was when you purchased it, in that case you do have the right to a full refund and disbanding of the purchase contract.
Mr TAP clearly didn't since the bit he was worried about getting into the EU rules and rendering his site illegal is already in the EU ToS. Even when that was pointed out to him he kept the sensationalist clickbait headline.
Mr TAP clearly didn't since the bit he was worried about getting into the EU rules and rendering his site illegal is already in the EU ToS. Even when that was pointed out to him he kept the sensationalist clickbait headline.
It does make you wonder what level of ‘research’ (or even basic thought) they do for their other blog posts.
"the Fansite will not post material that is disparaging, illegal or infringes on the rights of any third party or that damages (or that might damage) the reputation of Wargaming or of any of the Games.
The way i read this is that the addition the the EULA is just a legal way for WG to prevent them from slander. It doesn't mean fansites (very broad definition btw, is a youtube channel also a fansite?) can't be critical as long their message is based on facts. I think before this addition WG can already sue for slander but the addition to the EULA just gives them tools to shut down sites easier.
Howeverr. if you take #fochgate for instance (and other rants), from a legal point of view it could be interesting if WG would allow such vids. Then again, you have freedom of speech, so as long as you don't use any WG copyrighted material (ingame footage f.i.) i don't think WG have any chance of taking down an entire channel for that.
"the Fansite will not post material that is disparaging, illegal or infringes on the rights of any third party or that damages (or that might damage) the reputation of Wargaming or of any of the Games.
The way i read this is that the addition the the EULA is just a legal way for WG to prevent them from slander. It doesn't mean fansites (very broad definition btw, is a youtube channel also a fansite?) can't be critical as long their message is based on facts. I think before this addition WG can already sue for slander but the addition to the EULA just gives them tools to shut down sites easier.
Howeverr. if you take #fochgate for instance (and other rants), from a legal point of view it could be interesting if WG would allow such vids. Then again, you have freedom of speech, so as long as you don't use any WG copyrighted material (ingame footage f.i.) i don't think WG have any chance of taking down an entire channel for that.
At much easier reading of it is we’ll let you use some of our IPR to create a better looking website but don’t think you can do that and then just slag us off. Personally that hardly seems unreasonable.
Just read the Steam EULA (Steam Subscriber Agreement), you don't actually own anything and Valve can terminate your account at any time:
"You understand and acknowledge that Valve may decide to cease operation of any Subscription Marketplace, change the fees that it charges or change the terms or features of the Steam Subscription Marketplace. Valve shall have no liability to you because of any inability to trade Subscriptions in the Steam Trading Marketplace, including because of discontinuation or changes in the terms, features or eligibility requirements of any Subscription Marketplace."
3
