55 replies to this topic

[benerdeath]

Dear Wargaming,

 

Our clan has been involved in lots of clan wars before and soldiers of fortune was very hard for some reason. We were fighting a lot and winning a lot. But for some reason we were losing ground on points everyday. We have won in numerous advanced front. I suspect that the top clans were getting too much fame points and also staying in the basic front because they have no incentive to move to the advanced and elite fronts. I think that not allowing the 10% of clan fame point going to the other clan was a mistake. Top clans just did not care if they lose clan fame points. For example, our clan have won an advanced front battle against clan [TRVST] We Trust No One.  if we had the clan fame point transfer then our clan would have had enough fame points to bid for advanced fronts. 

 

Given these shortcomings in the rules, would you please increase the reward tank by extra 5000 people. I truly believe that people from 10000 to 15000 position deserve a tank reward. They have played through two weeks with non stop and collected substantial amount of fame point around 15000+. if you look at the fame points of players that missing out on the tank they have been playing everyday. Surely clan war is about the players who make the clan war great by participating everyday. Surely wargaming will have in their interest to reward them with a tank. Of course the extra things you can get with the fame points are nice but those are for people who are not playing it everyday. Is there a some sort of percentage points of players where reward tank is given out? I mean I can see that 55000 people participated in the clan war. Lets calculate some percentage points.

 

Top 20% -> 11000 people gets the tank. 

Top 25% -> 13750 people gets the tank. 

Top 30% -> 16500 people gets the tank. 

 

So if the wargaming intention from the beginning that top 25% gets a tank then at least reward tank should be increased to 13750.

 

I just noticed that only few person is getting a tank from certain clan. I mean team consists of at least 15 people. So how come only few gets a tank and the rest of them can't even though the fame points are very close. This feels very unfair to the whole team. 

 

Tank you, 

Executive commander

Edited by benerdeath, 04 February 2019 - 12:00 AM.

[B_Mockingjay]

is supporting. 15000+ 
Will be happy

[SchnipeExpert]

Believe in the dream buddy I also pray for it but i doubt it

[plutonium87]

15k fame points ain't that much? But idk

[kuzkowaa]

is supporting. 15000+ 
Will be happy 

[benerdeath]

plutonium87, on 03 February 2019 - 10:13 PM, said:

15k fame points ain't that much? But idk

 

It may not be much but it should be seen from an effort point of view. if you look at the points you will see that anyone with that kind of fame point would have played a lot of games. As an example, _Black_Tears_ from your clan seems to have played everyday but ended up not getting the tank. 

Edited by benerdeath, 04 February 2019 - 12:26 AM.

[Chase__xd]

Did you not invest in personal fame bonuses? 

[benerdeath]

Chase__xd, on 03 February 2019 - 11:21 PM, said:

Did you not invest in personal fame bonuses? 

 

Everybody in our clan invested with 1000 personal fame bonuses. Quite a few invested to 2500. I don't see the point of going above that. My point is people with decent fame points should get the tank.

[TheDutchMen]

Well to bad i guess. WG set a number and that is it nothing you can do about that to change it.

[benerdeath]

TheDutchMen, on 03 February 2019 - 11:33 PM, said:

Well to bad i guess. WG set a number and that is it nothing you can do about that to change it.

 

I don't agree with that they set a number and we can't do anything. 

if we assume that clan can win at least twice in an hour then roughly you would get 4 hours * 2wins = 8wins. if the win will get 100 point then you will get 800 a day. 14 * 800 = 11200. I think this whole advanced 5x multiplier is just so unforgiving for those who play consistently.

 

 

[Chase__xd]

benerdeath, on 04 February 2019 - 12:31 AM, said:

 

Everybody in our clan invested with 1000 personal fame bonuses. Quite a few invested to 2500. I don't see the point of going above that. My point is people with decent fame points should get the tank.

 

I went to level 4, my clan had a lower win rate, and I ended up with more points than you. Guess you guys messed up somewhere

[benerdeath]

Chase__xd, on 03 February 2019 - 11:43 PM, said:

 

I went to level 4, my clan had a lower win rate, and I ended up with more points than you. Guess you guys messed up somewhere

 

Not particularly. It was just the usual clan war with wins and losses. We haven't particularly played bad. I just feel very sorry for my clan team mates who were involved in for two week and not get a tank. I mean 30+ people over two weeks. That is a lot of effort. One of the particular problem of advanced is that we can't see who won the bid earlier. I don't understand why the bidding process can't finish two hour before the standard battle schedule. Our clan had the standard one a day advanced battles and we have won and lost as usual.

[cro001]

Chase__xd, on 04 February 2019 - 12:43 AM, said:

I went to level 4, my clan had a lower win rate, and I ended up with more points than you. Guess you guys messed up somewhere

 

Not scoring provinces really messes up the points for lesser clans. I saw RDDT on map, I don't recall ARAVT being on it?

[TheDutchMen]

You might have a point but how do you get so few points for the games? Didn't you invest at all or never got the points to do so. I mean 2 teams and that for 2 weeks seems to me you didn't do something right there.  

[Chase__xd]

TheDutchMen, on 04 February 2019 - 01:22 AM, said:

You might have a point but how do you get so few points for the games? Didn't you invest at all or never got the points to do so. I mean 2 teams and that for 2 weeks seems to me you didn't do something right there.

 

Im guessing they never ended up getting to land battles so couldn't get the good personal fame battles

[James_Potkukelkka]

These kind of campaings could be fun, if WG would give 20k tanks or something (average clan view). Now it feels too much work . GJ! all who win tank, and GL! to auction who didnt. 

[Keyhand]

So you think the point transfer mechanic was a good thing to happen, so that clans with a lot of points would only play with one team per evening whilst 40 ppl idle on ts as to not produce a defeat and also after investing you would simply spam battles against clans with points right now? think again.

 

Also, If you dont have enough points, then there are three possibilites:

*EDIT*

Its really that simple.

 

Additionally you even had the option to collect bonds to go for the action which enables complete bots to get the campaign rewards that other people work really hard for by simply spamming randoms and ranked.

In the first campaign, 3k tanks were given out and it actually carried a sense of accomplishment to drive your M60 back then which is no longer the case.

I hope WG doesnt water down the rewards even more than they already did.

 

Cheers

 

Also Executive Commander (As if that means anything)

 

Edit: as my honesty wasnt appreciated:

 

Here my opinion in OK letters (I hope)

You are not that good

Your clan isnt that good

both of the obove

 

However, if ya just aint that good, you always got the chicago blues friggin bothers

SWEET HOME CHICAGO

Edited by Keyhand, 05 February 2019 - 04:42 AM.
Inappropriate remarks

[James_Potkukelkka]

Keyhand, on 04 February 2019 - 06:19 AM, said:

So you think the point transfer mechanic was a good thing to happen, so that clans with a lot of points would only play with one team per evening whilst 40 ppl idle on ts as to not produce a defeat and also after investing you would simply spam battles against clans with points right now? think again.

 

Also, If you dont have enough points, then there are three possibilites:

*EDIT*

Its really that simple.

 

Additionally you even had the option to collect bonds to go for the action which enables complete bots to get the campaign rewards that other people work really hard for by simply spamming randoms and ranked.

In the first campaign, 3k tanks were given out and it actually carried a sense of accomplishment to drive your M60 back then which is no longer the case.

I hope WG doesnt water down the rewards even more than they already did.

 

Cheers

 

Also Executive Commander (As if that means anything)

 

Yeah but u have to remember, some of us have to go work, and have family. Its not easy if games are 20.00-00.45, if u have to wake up 05.30 . And yes I play for fun, and played 72 geims and get that pixel tonk. 

[Keyhand]

72 games is 4 days max of good activity with decent planning and decent winrate.

Not too much to ask tbh.

[Bornstaziel]

It's a reward base on personal and moreover clan skill and planning, not only activity. (Btw, thanks FCs)

That's it.

Edited by DrNovelzreal, 04 February 2019 - 08:38 AM.