8 replies to this topic

[ruleyouname]

Just some suggestions to make the team play less painful and more playable. 

Allow team to vote out players. if more than 5 team member agree to vote out a player than effects immediately and that vehicle gets banned for 5 min.

Any top tier player did zero damage after 10min (8 min in encounter)will get penalty for example 1000 credit. 

Any player with less than 45% win rate will get five free gold round each game and reset after game

 

 

 

 

 

 

[Homer_J]

So you are going to vote players out on the basis of what?  And how do you propose replacing them?

 

Doing no damage already gives you a penalty of much more than 1000 credits in high tiers.  Damage = credits, no damage = no credits.

 

I don't even know where you are going with that last suggestion.  Without 45% players your win rate would be lower.

[StronkiTonki]

The voting suggestion would be a good idea for on the forums for bad threads.

If 4 other people like my post, this thread should get deleted, and OP should get banned for 5 minutes. 

[NUKLEAR_SLUG]

This is a stupid idea. I can almost guarantee that if OP was selected for kick the required 5 people would instantly vote to kick him without question simply because they can. 

[ruleyouname]

Homer_J, on 08 November 2020 - 06:02 AM, said:

So you are going to vote players out on the basis of what?  And how do you propose replacing them?

 

Doing no damage already gives you a penalty of much more than 1000 credits in high tiers.  Damage = credits, no damage = no credits.

 

I don't even know where you are going with that last suggestion.  Without 45% players your win rate would be lower.

have you played rainbow 6? voting player out is not something new and widely accepted. you fail the team and team can punish you. 

1000 credit is just an example. could raise to 10000 just to motivate people to engage in team play instead of hiding away from battle.

and i can't understand your last argument. besides the game is not all about winrate. it's about effective team play. if your team worked together and got outplayed that's fine.  but if your team member played like moron but you still win just because enemy is more stupid I can't see the fun in it. 

Edited by ruleyouname, 08 November 2020 - 11:08 AM.

[lord_chipmonk]

1. Voting sounds like a terrible idea to me open to abuse. I don't see the benefit it could provide either, so no?

2. You already get penalised for having a poor game. Why would we wish to penalise them more?

3. Just why? In the random queue at least, I am not in favour of any measure to give a direct buff to poor players. Want to win more? Play better. Simple. 

 

Genuine suggestion: Strip out a lot of the junk that has crept into the garage UI. It is cluttered and in many cases not required. 

[Miepie]

ruleyouname, on 08 November 2020 - 05:58 AM, said:

Just some suggestions to make the team play less painful and more playable. 

Allow team to vote out players. if more than 5 team member agree to vote out a player than effects immediately and that vehicle gets banned for 5 min.

Any top tier player did zero damage after 10min (8 min in encounter)will get penalty for example 1000 credit. 

Any player with less than 45% win rate will get five free gold round each game and reset after game

 

 

 

 

 

 

I am confused. Do you keep the same team for several matches in Rainbow Six? Because then an option to change a teammate would make sense between battles. Voting someone off your "team" after a random battle makes no sense, since it would be highly unusual for them to be on your team again in the next random. Voting someone off during a match and leaving your team with one less player/tank? No thank you. Plus, you deny the enemy team a chance for damage and a kill which seems unfair for something they did not do.

Weird suggestion. 

 

3 Edits: typpöz 

Edited by Miepie, 08 November 2020 - 11:51 AM.

[Balc0ra]

ruleyouname, on 08 November 2020 - 05:58 AM, said:

Just some suggestions to make the team play less painful and more playable. 

Allow team to vote out players. if more than 5 team member agree to vote out a player than effects immediately and that vehicle gets banned for 5 min.

Any top tier player did zero damage after 10min (8 min in encounter)will get penalty for example 1000 credit. 

Any player with less than 45% win rate will get five free gold round each game and reset after gam

 

44% Steve has enough gold ammo, and tbh it will make zero difference for some if they have zero map awareness as is to where the "armored" target is hitting him from. 

 

As for the vote? No. Anything like that can be abused as much as just being a good tool to help with anything. And a 1000 credit penalty for no damage? That won't scare anyone of anything tbh. Then again if you increase it you can make it more unplayable too, as people just yolo to get more damage fast in fear of getting "credit sinked". So no... that won't help much either I suspect. 

[unhappy__bunny]

There is a pinned Suggestions thread.

However, OP I would suggest you give your ideas a little more thought before posting, and if you want to gain support from players, give a lot more detail about how you think they would work and the mechanics and finally , how gameplay would improve though them.

And do not try and justify a suggestion by comparison to another game that bears no resemblence to WoT. 

 

Closing this one.